JAKARTA, RAKYAT NEWS – Indonesia’s Minister of Human Rights, Natalius Pigai, has firmly rejected a proposal from his special staff member regarding the handling of a controversial case in Cidahu, Sukabumi.

The case involves allegations of forced dispersal and property damage during a Christian youth retreat, sparking debates over justice and reconciliation. Pigai made it clear that the suggestion to suspend the detention of suspects would not be pursued, emphasizing the need to prioritize the victims’ sense of justice.

The minister’s statement came after his special staff member, Thomas Harming Suwarta, floated the idea of restorative justice as a way to resolve the case. Suwarta argued that this approach could foster reconciliation and maintain social stability in the diverse community.

However, Pigai swiftly distanced himself from the proposal, calling it an individual opinion that did not reflect the ministry’s official stance. He stressed that any actions must align with national laws and the principles of Pancasila.

Pigai clarified that the Ministry of Human Rights has not yet taken an official position on the matter. The ministry is still awaiting a detailed report from the West Java Regional Office before making any formal decisions. This cautious approach underscores the sensitivity of the case, which has drawn significant public and media attention due to its religious and human rights implications.

Suwarta defended his suggestion, explaining that it was based on observations from the field and aimed at promoting peace. He emphasized that restorative justice would not replace legal accountability but could complement it by addressing underlying tensions. However, his proposal faced immediate backlash from critics who argue that intolerance and violence must be met with strict legal consequences.

YouTube player